Why Waiting for the Perfect Price Will Kill Your Returns (And What to Do Instead)
Welcome back, Fluenteer! 👋🏻
As a quality investor, you’ve honed your skills through years of research, discipline, and a knack for spotting exceptional companies. But one common mistake can quietly undermine your success:
Waiting for the perfect price to buy a stock.
This habit of chasing an ideal entry point often leads to missed opportunities and weaker returns. Below, I unpack why this approach is costly and share four practical strategies to overcome it
Happy compounding!
The Trap of Waiting for the Perfect Price
Waiting for the perfect price means holding off on buying a great company because its stock feels too expensive. You might hope for a market dip, a quarterly correction, or a valuation that matches your ideal target. Meanwhile, the stock climbs, and you’re left with cash or lesser investments, watching a world-class business slip away.
This isn’t about reckless buying. It’s about recognizing that great companies rarely trade at bargain prices, and the cost of waiting can outweigh the risk of paying a fair premium. Studies show that missing key growth periods in top-performing stocks can slash long-term returns. For example, a $10,000 investment in the S&P 500 from 1990 to 2020 grew to over $70,000; however, missing the 10 best days reduced that to $35,000. The same logic applies to individual stocks: delaying a purchase to save 10% can cost you multiples of that amount in future gains.
Why Investors Fall Into This Trap
Fear of Overpaying: Nobody wants to buy at a peak, but quality businesses often command premiums for a reason.
Anchoring Bias: You fixate on a lower price target, convinced the stock will “come to you.”
Overconfidence in Timing: Predicting short-term price movements is notoriously tricky, even for professionals.
Four Strategies to Act Smarter
To stop waiting for the perfect price, you need a mindset shift and a disciplined process. Here are four strategies to buy great companies at fair prices while managing risk.
1. Prioritize Business Quality Over Price
The best companies, those with strong moats, consistent cash flows, and top-tier management, deserve a fair price. Instead of chasing a low price-to-earnings ratio, focus on the company’s long-term value and resilience.
How to Do It:
Seek a Quality Margin of Safety: Buy businesses with durable advantages, such as high barriers to entry or loyal customer bases. These reduce the risk of permanent loss, even if the stock experiences a short-term dip.
Estimate Intrinsic Value Flexibly: Use a range for your valuation (e.g., $90-$110 per share). If the stock trades within this range, it’s likely a good buy.
Think Long-Term: Ask, “Will this price look reasonable in 10 years if the company keeps growing?” If yes, don’t wait for a small discount.
In 2010, many avoided Costco due to its “high” valuation. Those who bought anyway, trusting its customer loyalty and growth, saw the stock rise over 500% by 2020.
2. Build Positions Gradually
If a stock’s price feels steep but the business is stellar, don’t sit idle. Start with a partial position and gradually add to it over time to balance conviction with caution.
How to Do It:
Buy in Tranches: Commit 20% to 30% of your target position now. This gets you exposure without overcommitting.
Plan Add-On Points: Set price levels (e.g., a 5% or 10% dip) or time intervals (e.g., every quarter) to add more, assuming the thesis holds.
Stay Disciplined: Use limit orders or a written plan to avoid emotional decisions.
If a stock trades at $100, buy a quarter of your position today, add another quarter at $95, and more in three months if fundamentals stay strong. This smooths your entry cost.
3. Redefine Risk as Missing Out
Waiting often stems from fearing a price drop. But for quality investors, the bigger risk is missing a great company’s growth or settling for mediocre ones. Short-term volatility is normal; permanent loss is rare in top businesses.
How to Do It:
Focus on Fundamentals: Choose companies with low debt, high returns on capital, and diverse revenue streams. These traits cushion against lasting damage.
View Dips as Opportunities: A 10% drop in a great stock is a chance to buy more, not a reason to regret your entry.
Track Missed Gains: Compare your portfolio to stocks you skipped due to price. This highlights the true cost of waiting.
In 2018, Adobe’s stock appeared pricey following its rally. Investors who bought, banking on its cloud transition, saw gains of 100% or more by 2023, while cash holders lagged behind.
4. Train Yourself to Act
Perfectionism can paralyze quality investors. To counter this, build habits that favor action over endless waiting.
How to Do It:
Set a Research Deadline: After analyzing a stock, decide within a week whether to buy. This curbs overthinking.
Use a Buy Checklist: List criteria like revenue growth or competitive edge. If a company meets 80% of them, act.
Learn from Misses: Review stocks you passed on. Did they outperform? This builds confidence to pull the trigger next time.
The Power of Owning Quality Early
History proves that owning great businesses for the long haul drives wealth. A 2018 study found that 4% of U.S. stocks generated nearly all market gains from 1926 to 2016. Waiting for the perfect price risks missing these winners. Instead, buy quality at fair prices and let time work its magic.
Buffett once delayed buying Apple, citing concerns about its valuation. When he acted in 2016, the stock still delivered massive gains, showing that action trumps perfect timing.
Take Action Today
Waiting for the perfect price is a subtle but costly mistake. By valuing quality over bargains, entering positions gradually, redefining risk, and acting decisively, you can build a portfolio of exceptional companies that compound for years. Scan your watchlist now. Is there a great business you’ve been hesitating on? Use these strategies to act with confidence and unlock your portfolio’s full potential.
Ready to go from reading about great businesses to owning them with conviction?
✔️ Full research reports and timeless deep dives (valued at €1,597)
✔️ Monthly buy/sell portfolio updates with commentary (€987)
✔️ Access to a private Discord of high-conviction investors (€743)
✔️ Tools, templates, investor interviews & PDF briefs (€2,013)
Total value: €5,340, yours for just €44.99/month or €445/year.
No fluff. No noise. Just real work, trusted by 1,200+ long-term investors.
This isn’t just insight. It’s an investing advantage.
Delivered weekly. Backed by research. Built to compound.
🟢 Become one of The Fluent Few
Let’s build wealth the right way, brick by brick.
PS…. if you’re enjoying FluentInQuality, can you take 3 seconds to refer this edition to a friend? It will go a long way in helping me grow the newsletter (and bring more quality investors into the world).
Great investments don’t shout, they compound quietly.
- Yorrin (FluentInQuality)
Sources I Recommend
I use Finchat for all the charting, analysis, and keeping up with earnings calls. You can now get 15% off your subscription. Click here and start today!
I use Wise for all my domestic and international transfers. You can set up your Wise account within minutes by pressing here.
Disclaimer
By accessing, reading, or subscribing to my content, whether on Substack, social media, or elsewhere, you acknowledge and agree to my disclaimer. Read the full disclaimer here.